Sail Melbourne December 2023

Scoring Enquiries

IDDivisionRaceDateSail
Number
BoatSkipperRequestResponse     
30 Iq foil 14 03 Dec 20:47 Aus 321 IQ Foil Joseph Folley

I was given the result of 7th place in this race. I believe I scored 2nd place. This could potentially be verified through one of the coaches Mitch Pearson or Sailor Matthew Quinlan. Also I think t ....

Joesph, apologies for the error and results have now been updated. It was a mistake by our scorer, and in the rush on the last day our finish boat did not check them. I will arrange for a medal to ....

Closed
29 ILCA 6 7 03 Dec 17:57 222061 Paige Caldecoat

I finished behind 221161 and in front of  196435 (assuming he was not passed on the final upwind) but I have been scored 9.5 when there were no other boats within 10 boat lengths of me. < ....

Paige, apologies. A little mixup with BFDs just in front of you. You were 11th across the finish line and scored 9th due to BFDs to two boats in front of you. Scores have been corrected.


....
Closed
28 Tasar 6 03 Dec 17:49 2579 N/A I Kirkwood

We finished 6th in race 6 but it looks like we have been given a penalty but don't know why? 


You received a one point penalty for not signing off on the last day.


....
Closed
27 ILCA7 8 03 Dec 16:56 216899 George Gautrey

I finished 3rd not fourth 


Hi George, You did finish in 3rd place, but the results will show you finished with 4 points. As you received a scoring penalty for not signing off in the allocated time. The scoring penalty w ....

Closed
26 ILCA 6 7 03 Dec 16:20 220027 Frances Beebe

I finished 5th but have been scored 7th


Hi Frances, Your scores have been adjusted. Results now show you scoring 4 points with a finishing place of 5th. This is due to boat 218756 in 1st place receiving BFD


....
Closed
25 Opimist inter 5 03 Dec 16:15 SGP 3001 Tan Yee Xuen

I was in front of aus 1859 in race 5. I finished in 2nd place. But was scored 4th instead. Aus1859 was scored 2nd and 859 was scored 4th. There's no 3rd in the result.


Hi Tan Yee, You did finish in 3rd place, but the results will show you finished with 4 points. As you received a scoring penalty for not signing off in the allocated time. The scoring penalty ....

Closed
24 ILCA 7 7 03 Dec 16:13 224626 Deadlift Will Sargent

I was given bfd in race 7. There were 4 numbers on the white board after the race and I was not one of them. A similar number on the board to mine was on it. I believe this is a scoring error and w ....

Hi Will, Your BFD in race 7 is correct. Records show you've been sailing under both 224626 and 224646 in this regatta, which has resulted in a conflict in sail numbers for you on the Entry ....

Closed
23 Opimist open 6 03 Dec 16:13 SGP 3000 Tan Herng Yee

I was in front of aus 1599 in race 6. he finished in 5th place and in the results, I was also scored 5th. Instead, I should be 4th.


Hi Tan Hereng, You did finish in 4th place, but the results will show you finished with 5 points. As you received a scoring penalty for not signing off in the allocated time. The scoring penalty wi ....

Closed
22 Optimist open 6 03 Dec 14:34 1907 Bluebayou Acklin Stent

Approximately 50m into race six my lower rudder pin broke proventing me from continuing with the race having made every attempt to complete the race with a damaged rudder

I am seekin ....

Re-posted as a Request for Hearing


....
Closed
21 Waszp 3 02 Dec 17:36 2 Gbk Tom trotman

I am marked as 20th in race 3. In front of me was Tim Hannah and behind me was another Australian boat 


Thanks - all sorted 


....
Closed
19 Ilca 6 5 02 Dec 16:37 216200 WCPGW Robert

Listed as 1st, this is incorrect


There was an error putting the results into the system. This issue has been resolved.


....
Closed
18 ILCA 6 5 02 Dec 16:29 222061 Paige Caldecoat

I finished 5th behind Zoe but have been scored 7. 


There was an error putting the results into the system. This issue has been resolved.


....
Closed
17 ILCA6 5 02 Dec 16:23 208546 Croatian Supermarket Rage Mara Stransky

I finished this race 1st and have been scored 3rd


There was an error putting the results into the system. This issue has been resolved.


....
Closed
16 ILCA 6 5 02 Dec 16:22 218756 Elyse Ainsworth

The finishing order for race 5 was: 208546, 210792, 218756 and then 204568

 


There was an error putting the results into the system. This issue has been resolved.


....
Closed
15 ILCA 6 6 02 Dec 16:19 222061 Paige Caldecoat

I wish to hear/see the start boat recording. I do not believe I was over on the start line. 


Please come to the regatta office tomorrow morning at 10:15am. The race officer will make his tapes available for you to listen to.


....
Closed
13 ILCA 4 4 01 Dec 18:36 224223 Rooster Racing Wilbur Bright

Given a point penalty on the results in race 4 for what seems as no reason.


You were penalised 1 point for not signing off.


....
Closed
12 Ilca 4 4 01 Dec 18:30 202767 Sesto elements Olivia aitken

I got 17 points although I think I should've got 15/16 because I don't think I got a penalty. 


You were recorded by the RO as NSC, which is "Not sailed the correct course". You might want to talk to the RO, or check the SIs for the correct course to sail.


....
Closed
11 ILCA 4 4 01 Dec 18:13 202510 Long Time Molly Schotte

In race 4, I was scored 7th and tied with 207493, however I was infront of 207493 and I came 6th. Boat 207493 was behind me and came 7th. 


You were recorded as 6th across the line but received a one point penalty for not signing off


....
Closed
10 ILCA 6 Race 1 01 Dec 16:39 201504 Massive Owen McMahon

I finished one place behind Brendan Dukes. He has also put in a scoring enquiry. Yesterday we were scored as DNC. We believe we finished around 6 and 7.


We have referred to the video of Race 1. Results stand, no change to the current results.


....
Closed
9 ILCA 4 01 Dec 16:13 215085 Sailinn Zoe

I finished 10.


Have reviewed results sheets which show you finished 11th in Race 4


....
Closed
8 ILCA 6 1 01 Dec 16:11 206022 Jukes of HazArd Brendon Jukes

I do not believe the places you adjusted are correct from race one. I crossed Slyvia and Great and Owen at the finish. Slyvia wears a distinctive pink bower and head tie and I crossed a good six to ....

We have referred to the video of Race 1. Results stand, no change to the current results.


....
Closed
7 ILCA 4 1 30 Nov 17:53 223667 Laella India arkell

The boat in front of me 203784 didn't complete the course not going around the gate to the finishing line as they had fully missed the mark and continued sailing to the finish 


Hi India,

Race committee has no record of any boat sailing the incorrect course. This scoring inquiry will have to become a protest, to be followed through more.


....
Closed
5 ILCA 6 Race 1 30 Nov 16:02 206022 Jukes of Hazzard Brendon

I finished Race  1 in 6th of 7th place. But have been scored DNC


Hi Brendon, 

Your scoring enquiry has been processed. You did finish 9th for Race 1, this was found on the finishing tapes. Sail 201504 was also re-scored as finishing 10th for Race ....

Closed
4 ILCA 7 2 30 Nov 15:58 217361 Na Pat Cummins

Boat did not finish 13th sailor himself can confirm this. The boat was behind 223666 indefinitely.


Hi Pat, 

Your scoring enquiry has been processed, you did score 22nd. results have been updated. 


....
Closed
3 ILCA 7 2 30 Nov 15:55 217316 Ankle Busta Michael Compton

I was scored 22nd in the second race but finished in 13th behind Bermuda


Hi Michael, 

Your scoring enquiry has been processed and you have been scored as finishing in 13th. Resueslts have been updated. 


....
Closed

Results by SailingResults.net  Created 17 Jun 2024 06:27