Hearing Decision

Hearing Number: 02

Event: 2016 George Mac RegattaRace Number: 6
Protesting Boat: Race CommitteeProtested Boat: Cadet 186, 189, 181, 183, Pacer 2, 6
Submitted Date/time:  04 Dec 2016 12:15
Hearing Details: RC requesting redress

Facts Found

 

The National Es, Quests, Cadets and Pacers were racing in a combined fleet, competing against each other on yardstick.

The Course RO indicated to Cadet 186, 189, 181, 183 and Pacer 2 via the course rescue boats that they should go ashore, owing to a sudden increase in wind strength.

Cadet 186, 189, 181, 183 and Pacer 2 returned to shore and stayed ashore.

Pacer 6 and Quest 131 stayed on course and completed race 6.

The two National Es did not leave shore.


Conclusion

 

The Race Committee made an error in sending select boats ashore whilst allowing others to race.

Cadets 186, 189, 181, 183 and Pacer 2 scores have been made significantly worse through no fault of their own, owing to the error by the Race Committee.


Rule(s) applicable

 62.1(a), NOR 2.3, SI Appendix A

Decision

 

For races conducted on 4/12/2016, Cadets 186, 189, 181, 183 and Pacer 2 are to be awarded points equal to the average of their scores from races 1-5.


Jury Members

 Danielle Watkins (chair), John Philpot (scribe)

Signature

 

 


Results by SailingResults.net  Created 05 May 2024 10:31