Hearing Decision

Event: Race Number: 5
Protesting Boat: 206395Protested Boat: Race Committee
Submitted Date/time:  11 Dec 2014 14:11
Hearing Details: Race committee moved windward mark

Facts Found

 

Race 5 of Laser 4.7 class was sailed with Course I2.

Race start at 12:14.

The first finisher was at 12:53:26, therefore, the time limit of the race was 13: 08: 26.

After 40 minutes of racing the boat 206395 completed 2 legs of the course with 4 more legs remaining.

RC removed the mark1 45 minutes after the start.

 


Conclusion

 

RC made an error by removing the mark1 before the time limit expired.

However, from the time when RC removed the mark1, it wouldn’t have been possible for the boat 206395 to finish within 10 minutes from his position on the course.

The position of the course and the time remaining to him to finish the course was his fault alone.

His score was not made significant worsen.

 


Rule(s) applicable

 62.1

Decision

 

Redress denied.


Jury Members

 Michael Tam (Chairman), Bill Bell, Doug Sloan USA IJ, Masa Tanaka, Paul Zupan USA IJ

Signature

 

 


22 Dec 2024 19:30