Hearing Decision

Hearing Number: 09

Event: 2025 Musto Australian Optimist ChampionshipRace Number: 7
Protesting Boat: 1882Protested Boat: IND1632
Submitted Date/time:  14 Jan 2025 16:42
Hearing Details: Windward / Leeward incident

Facts Found

 

Procedural Matters

1. No boat took a Post-Race Penalty, the case was not withdrawn and proceeded to a hearing.

2. Mathew Quinlan (coach of 1632) and Marc Chapman (coach of 1882) attended the hearing as observers.

3. Tituan (1600) gave evidence during the hearing as a witness for 1882.

 

Facts Found

1. The wind was around 8 knots and there were no waves.

2. 1632 was sailing downwind on port tack, after rounding mark 2, while 1882 was sailing upwind also on port tack.

3. The boats were on converging courses with the bows pointing at each other.

4. When 1632 was 3 boat lengths from 1882, 1632 altered course to windward 

5. When the distance between 1632 and 1882 was approximetly 1.5 boat lengths, 1882 started bearing away.

6. 1882 slows his boat down and 1632 then crosses ahead of 1882.

7. 1882 then continued on her beat to windward. 

8. When the boats passed each other, there was a quarter boat length between them.

9. There was no contact.

10. Neither boat took a penalty.


Conclusion

 

1. When changing course, 1882 the right-of-way boat gave 1632 room to keep clear, and complied with RRS 16.1.

2. No rules were broken.


Rule(s) applicable

 RRS 11, 16.1

Decision

 

The protest is dismissed.


Jury Members

 Wayne Thompson AUS NJ NU (Chairman), Gurvinderpal Singh Julka IND IJ, Mark Gallagher AUS NJ, Mike Alison NZL IJ NU, Soma Pillai IND IJ

Signature

 

 


Results by SailingResults.net  Created 11 Aug 2025 20:08