Hearing Decision

Hearing Number: 05

Event: Hobie 16 World ChampionshipsRace Number: 4
Protesting Boat: 08 - MacFarlaneProtested Boat: 12 - De la Guardia Llanso
Submitted Date/time:  07 Nov 2019 12:34
Hearing Details: Pre-start, windward/leeward

Facts Found

 

  1. 20 seconds prior to the start 08 and 12 both on starboard with 12 to weather of 08 and overlapped within 1m

  2. At 20 seconds, 15 seconds and 10 seconds, 08 called "up" to 12

  3. 12 did not initially alter course

  4. At less than 5 seconds to the start signal, 12 sheeted in and accellerated with less than 1m between the two boats

  5. There was no contact between the boats

  6. The wind was 8-10 knots

  7. No boats took any penalty turns

 

 

 

 


Conclusion

 

Boat 12 failed to keep clear as the windward boat


Rule(s) applicable

 11

Decision

 12 is DSQ in Race 4

Jury Members

 Matt Bounds USA NJ (Chairman), Francisco Jaurequi MEX IJ, Paul Pascoe AUS IJ, Rick Mallinson USA IJ, Walter Mielke GER IJ

Signature