Hearing Decision

Hearing Number: 23

Event: Gill OptiAus 2019Race Number: 8
Protesting Boat: 1449, 558, 946, 1756, 1769, 593, 1090, 977, RC on behalf of places 1-6Protested Boat: RC
Submitted Date/time:  10 Jan 2019 16:41
Hearing Details: Mistaken missing mark signal

Facts Found

 

Gate mark missing

RC boat dispatched to replace mark by displaying M and holding position.

Boat mistakenly displayed N instead of M for a short time.

Roundings were not taken

558 was leading at the mark and thought that the race had been abandoned and heading back to the start.

1756 thought the flag signaled abandonment and went back to the start and then realised mistake and lost 30 positions.

997 thought it was abandoned and only realised when returned to the start.

1769 was coming second when believed the race was abandoned and returned to the start.

1111 thought the race was abandoned.

946 was coming second and returned to the start 


Conclusion

 

The positions of 1449, 558, 1756, 997, 1769, 1090, 1111 and 946 were made worse by the failure of the RC to display the correct signal at the missing mark and through no fault of their own. 


Rule(s) applicable

 

Decision

 

Redress granted. The positions of the boats are to be scored


  • 1449   10

  • 558     1

  • 1756    5

  • 977     11

  • 1769     3

  • 1090     4

  • 1111    15

  • 946       2

No changes are to be made to the scores of other boats.


Jury Members

 Murray Jones IJ (Chair), Darren Eger NJ, Jeremy Atkinson NJ, Paddy Hodgman SJ

Signature

 

 


Results by SailingResults.net  Created 05 May 2024 21:23