Hearing Decision

Hearing Number: 00014/2026

Event: Sorrento Sailing Couta Boat ClubRace Number: One
Protesting Boat: C41Protested Boat: C82
Submitted Date/time:  28 Feb 2026 15:53
Hearing Details: Start Line

Procedural Matters

 

PC member Berine O'Hanlon was onboard a boat that participated in the race. It was noted the race was abandoned, to the outcome of the protest was unlikely to impact the score or places of other boats. All parties agreed to the participation of each member of the PC.                                              After taking evidence the protest was found to be valid

 


Facts Found

 

3 Piers Race for Division 1 Couta Boats.                                                                                          

 Sea was flat calm, wind 5 knots from the East/South East, significant out-going tide stream flowing from start pin towards the RC start vessel.                                                                                         

Start line was biased such that, in the conditions pertaining during the start sequence, the first mark, which was to be rounded to starboard, could be fetched crossing the line on port tack, pin end, and maintaining that course without tacking.                                                                                             

 At one minute prior to the start C41 was approaching the pin end of the line, close hauled on Port tack.                                                                                                                                                       

C82 was also on Port tack fetching the pin end of the line, sailing at least 10 degrees below close hauled and overlapped about 5 lengths to windward of C41 and on a converging course.

As C41 and C82 closed, C41 hailed C82 to keep clear, which hail was heard by C82.                       

 When the boats came within a boat width of one another, (approx 3m separation) C82 was still overlapped to windward of C41, the boats still on a converging course, and C41 hailed 'I am taking avoiding action'.  C82 heard the hail and observed C41 bearing away, altering course to leeward. 

There was no contact (and no damage or injury)

There were boats to windward of C82, but not in such proximity as to prevent C82 from avoiding contact with C41.

C82 believed she was right of way boat and took no action to avoid contact with C41.

Had C41 not altered course, contact would have occurred between her windward side and the leeward side of C82.

Neither boat took a penalty and both boats continued to race until, at a time when both were on the first leg of the course, the wind having dropped, the RC signalled “N over A’”.  

 

 

 

                               

 


Conclusion

 

C82, to windward failed to keep clear of C41 to leeward, and broke Rule 11


Rule(s) applicable

 11, 36

Decision

 

Since the race was abandoned, and C82 caused neither serious injury or damage, she shall not be penalised (as per Rule 36).....If the race is resailed, C82 may compete in the resail without penalty. Rule 36


Jury Members

 Peter Hannah NJ, Tony Weeks, Bernie O'Hanlon

Signature

 

 


Results by SailingResults.net  Created 20 Mar 2026 12:16