Hearing Decision

Hearing Number: 01

Event: Race Number: 3
Protesting Boat: 1332Protested Boat: 883
Submitted Date/time:  12 Jan 2016 17:33
Hearing Details: Leeward Mark

Facts Found

 

  1. Bow 46 approached the leeward gate on starboard gybe running deep with spinnaker

  2. 04 approached the mark clear astern of 46

  3. 02 on starboard gybe with an inside overlap on 46 and 04

  4. All boats dropped their spinnaker as they entered the zone

  5. 15 rounded the mark clear ahead of all three boats

  6. 46 rounded wide to give room for 15 clear ahead and 02 inside

  7. 02 followed clear astern of 15 around the mark

  8. 04 established an inside overlap on 46 and attempted to clear the stern of 46 but was prevented from doing so by a collision with 02

  9. There was contact between the bow of 04 and the port quarter of 46 causing serious damage.

  10. The collision caused the bow of 46 to make contact with the starboard quarter of 15. 

  11. 46 retired from the race due to the damage

  12. No boats exhonerated themselves


Conclusion

 

  1. 02 was entitled to mark room from 46 and mark room was given

  2. 02 was entitled to mark room from 04 but it was not given

  3. 46 was entitled to mark room from 04, but it was not given

  4. It was not reasonably possibly for 02 or 46 to avoid contact


Rule(s) applicable

 18.2(b), 14

Decision

 

  1. Bow 04 DSQ in Race 3

  2. 46 Granted average points in R3 equal the average of all races sailed Tuesday - Thursday excluding R3.


Jury Members

 

Signature

 

 


Results by SailingResults.net  Created 07 May 2024 17:42